The NFL adopted a new rule for overtime yesterday but only for the playoffs. It's idiotic, idiotic, idiotic. The new rule allows for a team to tie or win if they lose the coin flip in overtime, kickoff, and limit the team with first possession to a field goal. If the game is still tied after 60 minutes and one possession each, the game goes into sudden death. No idea why that's more palatable to anyone.
These softer overtime rules will only reward gutlessness and were totally unnecessary. The NFL has plenty of gutlessness already. Overtime should be severe. It should be a deterrent. Teams should not want to take their chances in overtime. Teams should play to win in the 60 minutes of regulation. Furthermore, in the name of fairness and in their war on placekickers, the NFL did the one thing they wanted to eliminate: They heightened the importance of the coin flip. The flip is more important now than it was yesterday. On a related note, why not eliminate the coin flip altogether. The home team kicks off to start the game and the visitor kicks off after halftime. There is no coin flip in baseball. The home team takes the field to start the game. The NFL should do the same. It ensures fairness and eliminates the quirks of randomness, like the NFC winning 13 straight coin flips in the Super Bowl. I digress. With the rule passed yesterday, teams will get/have to decide whether to receive or defer possession. The rule should have made that impossible. It should have been written so that a team can't defer or if they do, they also give up the right of possession if the other team scores. There should be no strategy whatsoever attached to the flip of the coin.
This ridiculous rule change was driven by a couple of influential sportswriters. They're crying because a team could get a decent kickoff return, a couple of first downs, and be in range for a field goal to win the game without the desired winner other team touching the ball. That's not football to them. I have two better ideas. First, why play the game at all? Let the sportswriters determine the outcome they like and let them write about it. That would reduce injuries substantially.
Second, and for what it's worth, the CrabAppleLane overtime suggestion: Sudden death ... first team to score wins. If the game was tied by a field goal or extra point, the team who kicked it is responsible for the tie when they could have done something else to win. They should kickoff to start the overtime. If the game was tied by a two-point conversion or a safety, that's desirable and the two teams would switch sides at the end of the fourth quarter and keep playing until someone scores. No more coin flips.
- Day 5 of CrabAppleLane PC recovery ...
- CrabAppleLane iTunes library recover & rebuild stands at 603 songs, 1.9 days, 5.39GB ...
- Still no hummingbirds at CrabAppleLane ...
- 169 days until football season ...
5 song iTune shuffle:
- Rattlesnake Shake - Then Play On - Fleetwood Mac
- Brothers In Arms - Live From The Ryman - Mark Knopfler
- Cryptorchid - Antichrist Superstar - Marilyn Manson
- Long Way To Go - Rock & Roll - Foghat
- Stockton Gala Days - MTV Unplugged - 10,000 Maniacs
Quote of the Day
The National Football League owners have approved a change in overtime, starting with the playoffs following the 2010 season, that will modify the sudden-death format and prevent a team from winning a game with a field goal on the opening possession.
Michael David Smith,
Blog of the day is here.
Quote from said blog: "As recently as yesterday, discussions regarding changes in overtime were to be tabled until May. First healthcare reform, now this. I guess it is time to start the countdown to 2012."